Summary

Cassette 5: Side A

When Tony leaves Rosie’s, Tony calls him. He tells Clay to get into his car, and Clay obeys. As soon as Clay shuts his door, Tony tells him that he has the second set of tapes. Tony finds out which tape Clay is about to listen to. When he finds out, he tells Clay he will tell him why he has the second set of tapes after Clay listens to the next tape. He wants Clay to listen to that tape while he is in Tony’s car because the next tape is about Clay. Clay cries as he starts the tape.

In this tape, Hannah admits she had always wanted to get to know Clay better because all she’d ever heard about him was good. Hannah says that generally if a person seems that good, they...