The Ballad of Never After follows the journey of Evangeline Fox, who finds herself in a mysterious place called the Hollow. There, she encounters Jacks, a captivating and enigmatic figure. As their paths intertwine, Evangeline discovers magical elements, including the Mirth Stone, which influences emotions. Jacks, harboring a dark secret, reveals his quest for four stones that will allow him to travel back in time. The story takes unexpected turns as Apollo, a prince with a cursed destiny, enters the scene.

Evangeline and Jacks face challenges, confronting the consequences of magical objects and a mirroring curse. As they venture into Chaos' castle to open the Valory Arch, secrets unravel. Castor Valor, revealed as Chaos, emerges without his mantle, leading to a poignant reunion with his family. Tragedy strikes as Chaos, unable to control his vampiric instincts, attacks Evangeline. In a desperate act, Jacks uses the stones to travel back in time, altering the course of events.

The narrative circles back to the prior scenes, but this time, Jacks joins Evangeline and Chaos. Unaware of Jacks' time-travel, Chaos and Evangeline proceed to open the Valory Arch. Inside, they encounter the preserved Valors, and Evangeline learns the truth about Chaos. In a heart-wrenching twist, Jacks sacrifices himself to save Evangeline, revealing himself as the Handsome Stranger from her dreams. The story concludes with Apollo erasing Evangeline's memories, leaving her in an altered reality.

The Ballad of Never After weaves a tale of love, sacrifice, and the intricate interplay of time and fate. The characters' evolution, magical elements, and symbolic motifs contribute to a rich and engaging narrative.