Hair Tie

Annie finds a pink hair tie in her mother's bathroom that is similar to one she saw in the shed at the cabin that was around a bunch of money in the Freak's things. The police are later able to prove the two hair ties came from the same package, proving Annie's mother gave money to the Freak.

Gold Necklace

The Freak gives Annie a gold necklace with a heart on it as a gift during her captivity. The Freak tells Annie he bought the necklace for another woman and Annie finds herself wondering if the Freak killed the other girl.

Baby Blanket

After returning from taking care of the corpse of Annie's baby, the freak gives her the baby's blanket. This causes Annie to hope briefly the baby is still alive and to fly into a rage when she realizes it is just a blanket...