Summary

Chapter 32 takes place in 1985. Ben and the others burned their clothes after killing the cows, destroying any evidence of what happened. Trey insisted that Ben had failed, and Ben was angry that Diondra wouldn't stick up for him. He felt like everyone else was able to get through life without hassle, but he’s never caught a break. Diondra received several messages about Ben being wanted by the police. She panicked and told him they had to run now and he needed to get whatever money he could from his home since she only had a couple hundred dollars.

Chapter 33 is back in the present. Lyle brings up the tattoo that Libby saw on Ben, guessing that the name was Polly. He searches online and finds a Polly Palm that doesn’t live too far away. Libby calls and asks for Diondra, and...