The title of the novel itself gives the reader an early indication that the normally serious subject of murder will be treated lightly and ironically in the pages that follow. In fact, for a mystery novel, Murder in a Pig's Eye is remarkably free of blood or violence of any kind. However, Hall does not condescend in a sentimental way to either her characters or her young audience.

She recognizes, for example, that it is quite natural for Bodie and his adolescent friends to speculate in chilling detail about the gruesome possibilities suggested by Bella Siler's disappearance, and the reader is prompted to speculate right along with them. But the emphasis throughout the book is on humor, sprightly characterization, innocent suspense, and low farce. Even the most fastidious or squeamish of readers will find little to object to in Murder in a Pig's Eye.