1. In his argument against racial profiling, David A. Harris argues that pretextual traffic stops damage the credibility of the criminal justice system. However, John Derbyshire asserts that police stop and question minorities because of negative but accurate stereotypes. After reading their viewpoints, what is your opinion on these traffic stops? Are law enforcement officers justified in their actions? Explain your answers. 2. One argument against mandatory minimum drug sentences, as noted by Maxine Waters, is that such sentences eliminate judicial discretion. In his viewpoint in favor of mandatory minimums, George Allen contends that these sentences reflect the desires of most Americans. Do you believe that sentencing, whether for drug possession or other crimes, should be based on a judge’s interpretation of the laws or on public opinion? What are the advantages and disadvantages to both approaches? Explain your answers.

3. Laurence H. Tribe and Wendy Kaminer...