After considering the evidence and alternative explanations, it is time to make a judgment, to decide whether the hypothesis makes sense. You can tally up the evidence that does and does not support the hypothesis and see how many pros and cons you have. But that is really too simple. You will have to give more weight to some pieces of evidence than to others. What do you think is Price's most convincing evidence? Is it sufficiently convincing that you agree that Borley Rectory must be haunted".