English & Literature

Compare and contrast My Oedipus complex and Eleven

Asked by
Last updated by anonymous
1 Answers
Log in to answer

My Oedipus Complex, Frank O'Connor writes of a young child who is forced to deal with issues of confusion and jealousy through a first person point of view. Through O'Connor's elements of facetiousness and truth, he explains how such issues create a sort of ironic domins effect and, in this case can actually bring people closer together. In the beginning, the young boy displays signs of excitement and contentment when his father arrives unexpectedly on his visits from the war. His "pleasant musty smell" and "Santa Claus entrances and exits" intrigue him. As long as his daily routines are uninterrupted, he remains in a state of appeasement. The juvinile knows nothing of the problems the mother and father are facing. He is confined to a world all his own. If the point of view were changed in such a situation, then the father may tell of how naive and innocentthe child is or how oblivios he is to what a horrible condition they are faced with. The plot would change drastically. If the point of view were changed to the third person objective, or dramatic point of view, then the readers would assume their own emotion which would absolutely change the tone of this short story. Other elements such as theme could also be altered if this was seen in third person. The child's feeling of hostility toward his father could only be seen through this example first person point of view.

In the book, Eleven, the protagonist, too, is young and searching. Both are a coming of age story, and both have absentee parents that are in and out of their lives. Both grow angry and frustrated at the lack of information that they recieve in regard to their past, and understandably, are worried about their own futures. Both boys find themselves in an insular world of their own construction and must learn how to meet and exceed boundaries that have been set for them (by themselves and by others).