Private Peaceful
Why does Tommy give up all hope of Charlie returning to the dugout alive?
why
![](https://d22o6al7s0pvzr.cloudfront.net/images/bookrags/qa/avatars/.defaults/unknown.png)
Asked by
Caysan
Last updated by
Jill W
why
Chapter please? In the chapter, Five to Five, Charley refuses to leave Tommy behind in the dugout, and as a result, he is sentenced to death for disobeying orders. Do you have a chapter number for your question?