The story takes place in modern-day New York City, although the mythical element of magic is added. The setting is easily understood and the author uses common items, emotions and events for comparison. In the beginning of the story, Sally and Gillian live in a house with their two aunts. While this is where they grow up, Sally is certain that she is not wanted here and never truly seems to view this place as her home. The relationship between the family members changes to the point that, eventually, this is where Sally wants to come and visit. The story ends with all of the family members at the aunts' home.