In defense of Queen Isabella and the many religious men who traveled to the New World, I believe that their intentions were genuine and honest.... that their purpose was to convert, assist, and educate the Native Americans. These missionaries protected the Native Americans amidst the bloodshed, they reported the atrocities to the king, and they had faith that the evil commanders, who hindered their mission would be replaced. Sadly, this did not happen and many of these missionaries sacrificed their own lives for the people they described as gentle, kind, and free of all sin.
The Spanish soldiers, however, were a different story. First, we have to consider the large number of soldiers sent to the new World..... and what their purpose actually was. Beyond that, we must look at the weakness of men..... namely the bloodlust, greed, and to use a more modern term "gold fever" of the men who traveled to the New World. Historically, greed is one of the largest, if not largest, motivators of men. Over time, the word of riches spread, and yes, I believe that the thought of "riches" motivated those who were sent to the New World. I question King Ferdinand's lack of response when he was apprised of the atrocities committed in his name, and I find it hard to imagine that his intentions aligned with those of his wife.
Thus, I would have to say that Hautey's argument is sound after the fact, rather than initially. This, of course, is my opinion.
