Art is approached in different forms, but most serve a purpose, or can be construed in different manners. Just who can tell what the true intention is? The intention of the artist remains a mystery to all but the original author. This critique supplied by James on Besant's pamphlet is the basis for his attack on the superficial works titled "The Art of Fiction." Henry James argues that there are no set rules for art, or the artistic impression that is stained in ones memory. James rebuts Besant's pamphlet by stating there is a relationship between fiction and life, and that the important question to ask a text is whether or not it has a vital flame.

Fiction it seems, is not merely "make believe" but important in culture. Novelists bring out "Proof of life and curiosity", as their works serve for the purpose to entertain while attempting...