About the middle of the afternoon Sheridan advanced.  He sent his cavalry by both flanks, and they penetrated to the enemy’s rear.  The contest was close for a time, but at length the left of the enemy broke, and disintegration along the whole line soon followed.  Early tried to rally his men, but they were followed so closely that they had to give way very quickly every time they attempted to make a stand.  Our cavalry, having pushed on and got in the rear of the Confederates, captured twenty-four pieces of artillery, besides retaking what had been lost in the morning.  This victory pretty much closed the campaigning in the Valley of Virginia.  All the Confederate troops were sent back to Richmond with the exception of one division of infantry and a little cavalry.  Wright’s corps was ordered back to the Army of the Potomac, and two other divisions were withdrawn from the valley.  Early had lost more men in killed, wounded and captured in the valley than Sheridan had commanded from first to last.

On more than one occasion in these engagements General R. B. Hayes, who succeeded me as President of the United States, bore a very honorable part.  His conduct on the field was marked by conspicuous gallantry as well as the display of qualities of a higher order than that of mere personal daring.  This might well have been expected of one who could write at the time he is said to have done so:  “Any officer fit for duty who at this crisis would abandon his post to electioneer for a seat in Congress, ought to be scalped.”  Having entered the army as a Major of Volunteers at the beginning of the war, General Hayes attained by meritorious service the rank of Brevet Major-General before its close.

On the north side of the James River the enemy attacked Kautz’s cavalry on the 7th of October, and drove it back with heavy loss in killed, wounded and prisoners, and the loss of all the artillery.  This was followed up by an attack on our intrenched infantry line, but was repulsed with severe slaughter.  On the 13th a reconnoissance was sent out by General Butler, with a view to drive the enemy from some new works he was constructing, which resulted in heavy loss to us.

On the 24th I ordered General Meade to attempt to get possession of the South Side Railroad, and for that purpose to advance on the 27th.  The attempt proved a failure, however, the most advanced of our troops not getting nearer than within six miles of the point aimed for.  Seeing the impossibility of its accomplishment I ordered the troops to withdraw, and they were all back in their former positions the next day.

Butler, by my directions, also made a demonstration on the north side of the James River in order to support this move, by detaining there the Confederate troops who were on that side.  He succeeded in this, but failed of further results by not marching past the enemy’s left before turning in on the Darby road and by reason of simply coming up against their lines in place.