that were in like circumstances to the case before us.  I would not have the main strength of his case betrayed in complaisance to me.  Nothing can be more material than to show a fraud of this kind, that prevailed universally in the world.  Christ Jesus declared himself a Prophet, and put the proof of his mission on this, that he should die openly and publickly, and rise again the third day.  This surely was the hardest plot in the world to be managed; and if there be one instance of this kind, or in any degree like it, by all means let it be produced.

Mr. A. My Lord, There has hardly been an instance of a false religion in the world, but it has also afforded a like instance to this before us.  Have they not all pretended to inspiration?  Upon what foot did Pythagoras, Numa, and others set up?  Did they not all converse with the gods, and pretend to deliver oracles?

Mr. B. This only shews, that revelation is by the common consent of mankind the very best foundation of religion; and therefore every imposter pretends to it.  But is a man’s hiding himself in a cave for some years, and then coming out into the world, to be compared to a man’s dying, and rising to life again?  So far from it, that you and I and every man may do the one, but no man can do the other.

Mr. A. Sir, I suppose it will be allowed to be as great a thing to go to heaven, and converse with angels, and with God, and to come down to earth again, as it is to die, and rise again?  Now, this very thing Mahomet pretended to do; and all his disciples believe it.  Can you deny this fact?

Mr. B. Deny it, Sir?  No.  But tell us who went with Mahomet?  Who were his witnesses?  I expect, before we are done, to hear of the guards set over the sepulchre of Christ, and the seal of the stone.  What guard watched Mahomet in his going or returning?  What seals and credentials had he?  He himself pretends to none.  His followers pretend to nothing but his own word.  We are now to consider the evidence for Christ’s resurrection, and you think to parallel it, by producing a case for which no one ever pretended there was any evidence.  You have Mahomet’s word; and no man ever told a lie, but you had his word for the truth of what he said:  and therefore you need not go round the globe to find such instances as these.  But this story, it is said, has gained great credit, and is received by many nations.  Very well.  And how was it received?  Was not every man converted to this faith with the sword at his throat?  In our case, every witness to the resurrection, and every believer of it, was hourly exposed to death.  In the other case, whoever refused to believe, died; or, what was as bad, lived a wretched conquered slave.  And will you pretend these cases to be alike?  One case indeed there was, within our own memory, which, in some circumstances, came near to the case now before us.  The French prophets put the credit of their mission upon the resurrection of Dr. Emmes, and gave publick notice of it.  If the Gentleman pleases to make use of this instance, it is at his service.