the guidance of nature, and we are resisting it; we
listen to what she says to our senses, and we neglect
what she says to our heart; the active being obeys,
the passive commands. Conscience is the voice
of the soul, the passions are the voice of the body.
It is strange that these voices often contradict each
other? And then to which should we give heed?
Too often does reason deceive us; we have only too
good a right to doubt her; but conscience never deceives
us; she is the true guide of man; it is to the soul
what instinct is to the body, [Footnote: Modern
philosophy, which only admits what it can understand,
is careful not to admit this obscure power called
instinct which seems to guide the animals to some
end without any acquired experience. Instinct,
according to some of our wise philosophers, is only
a secret habit of reflection, acquired by reflection;
and from the way in which they explain this development
one ought to suppose that children reflect more than
grown-up people: a paradox strange enough to
be worth examining. Without entering upon this
discussion I must ask what name I shall give to the
eagerness with which my dog makes war on the moles
he does not eat, or to the patience with which he
sometimes watches them for hours and the skill with
which he seizes them, throws them to a distance from
their earth as soon as they emerge, and then kills
them and leaves them. Yet no one has trained
him to this sport, nor even told him there were such
things as moles. Again, I ask, and this is a more
important question, why, when I threatened this same
dog for the first time, why did he throw himself on
the ground with his paws folded, in such a suppliant
attitude .....calculated to touch me, a position which
he would have maintained if, without being touched
by it, I had continued to beat him in that position?
What! Had my dog, little more than a puppy, acquired
moral ideas? Did he know the meaning of mercy
and generosity? By what acquired knowledge did
he seek to appease my wrath by yielding to my discretion?
Every dog in the world does almost the same thing
in similar circumstances, and I am asserting nothing
but what any one can verify for himself. Will
the philosophers, who so scornfully reject instinct,
kindly explain this fact by the mere play of sensations
and experience which they assume we have acquired?
Let them give an account of it which will satisfy
any sensible man; in that case I have nothing further
to urge, and I will say no more of instinct.] he who
obeys his conscience is following nature and he need
not fear that he will go astray. This is a matter
of great importance, continued my benefactor, seeing
that I was about to interrupt him; let me stop awhile
to explain it more fully.