easily. It is no task for suns to shine.
And it will bring back many pleasant remembrances
to the minds of many readers, to open these new volumes,
and find themselves at once in the same kindly atmosphere
as ever; to find that the old spring is flowing yet.
The new series of Friends in Council is precisely what
the intelligent reader must have expected. A
thoroughly good writer can never surprise us.
A writer whom we have studied, mused over, sympathized
with, can surprise us only by doing something eccentric,
affected, unworthy of himself. The more thoroughly
we have sympathized with him; the more closely we
have marked not only the strong characteristics which
are already present in what he writes, but those little
matters which may be the germs of possible new characteristics;
the less likely is it that we shall be surprised by
anything he does or says. It is so with the author
of Friends in Council. We know precisely what
to expect from him. We should feel aggrieved
if he gave us anything else. Of course there will
be much wisdom and depth of insight; much strong practical
sense: there will be playfulness, pensiveness,
pathos; great fairness and justice; much kindness
of heart; something of the romantic element; and as
for Style, there will be language always free from
the least trace of affectation; always clear and comprehensible;
never slovenly; sometimes remarkable for a certain
simple felicity; sometimes rising into force and eloquence
of a very high order: a style, in short, not
to be parodied, not to be caricatured, not to be imitated
except by writing as well. The author cannot sink
below our expectations; cannot rise above them.
He has already written so much, and so many thoughtful
readers have so carefully studied what he has written,
that we know the exact length of his tether, and he
can say nothing for which we are not prepared.
You know exactly what to expect in this new work.
You could not, indeed, produce it; you could not describe
it, you could not say beforehand what it will be;
but when you come upon it, you will feel that it is
just what you were sure it would be. You were
sure, as you are sure what will be the flavour of
the fruit on your pet apple-tree, which you have tasted
a hundred times. The tree is quite certain to
produce that fruit which you remember and like so well;
it is its nature to do so. And the analogy holds
further. For, as little variations in weather
or in the treatment of the tree—a dry season,
or some special application to the roots—may
somewhat alter the fruit, though all within narrow
limits; so may change of circumstances a little affect
an author’s writings, but only within a certain
range. The apple-tree may produce a somewhat different
apple; but it will never producn an orange, neither
will it yield a crab.