But Mr. Trevor possessed a daughter who amply made up for his shortcomings.  She was the only one who could meet Farrar on his own ground, and rarely a meal passed that they did not have a tilt.  They filled up the holes of the conversation with running commentaries, giving a dig at the luckless narrator and a side-slap at each other, until one would have given his oath they were sworn enemies.  At least I, in the innocence of my heart, thought so until I was forcibly enlightened.  I had taken rather a prejudice to Miss Trevor.  I could find no better reason than her antagonism to Farrar.  I was revolving this very thing in my mind one day as I was paddling back to the inn after a look at my client’s new pier and boat-houses, when I descried Farrar’s catboat some distance out.  The lake was glass, and the sail hung lifeless.  It was near lunch-time, and charity prompted me to head for the boat and give it a tow homeward.  As I drew near, Farrar himself emerged from behind the sail and asked me, with a great show of nonchalance, what I wanted.

“To tow you back for lunch, of course,” I answered, used to his ways.

He threw me a line, which I made fast to the stern, and then he disappeared again.  I thought this somewhat strange, but as the boat was a light one, I towed it in and hitched it to the wharf, when, to my great astonishment, there disembarked not Farrar, but Miss Trevor.  She leaped lightly ashore and was gone before I could catch my breath, while Farrar let down the sail and offered me a cigarette.  I had learned a lesson in appearances.

It could not have been very long after this that I was looking over my batch of New York papers, which arrived weekly, when my eye was arrested by a name.  I read the paragraph, which announced the fact that my friend the Celebrity was about to sail for Europe in search of “color” for his next novel; this was already contracted for at a large price, and was to be of a more serious nature than any of his former work.  An interview was published in which the Celebrity had declared that a new novel was to appear in a short time.  I do not know what impelled me, but I began at once to search through the other papers, and found almost identically the same notice in all of them.

By one of those odd coincidents which sometimes start one to thinking, the Celebrity was the subject of a lively discussion when I reached the table that evening.  I had my quota of information concerning his European trip, but I did not commit myself when appealed to for an opinion.  I had once known the man (which, however, I did not think it worth while to mention) and I did not feel justified in criticising him in public.  Besides, what I knew of him was excellent, and entirely apart from the literary merit or demerit of his work.  The others, however, were within their right when they censured or praised him, and they did both.  Farrar, in particular, surprised me by the violence of his attacks, while Miss Trevor took up the Celebrity’s defence with equal ardor.  Her motives were beyond me now.  The Celebrity’s works spoke for themselves, she said, and she could not and would not believe such injurious reports of one who wrote as he did.