First and most astounding of disillusions of passing childhood, it was not a cave at all!  And yet the word “disillusion” does not apply.  It was, after all, the most enchanting and exciting of spots, to make one’s eye shine and one’s heart beat.  Under the trees were hundreds of tables surrounded by hovering ministering angels in white, and if you were German, they brought you beer; if American, ice-cream.  Beyond the tables was a stage, with footlights already set and orchestra tuning up, and a curtain on which was represented a gentleman making decorous love to a lady beside a fountain.  As in a dream, Honora followed Peter to a table, and he handed her a programme.

“Oh, Peter,” she cried, “it’s going to be ’Pinafore’!”

Honora’s eyes shone like stars, and elderly people at the neighbouring tables turned more than once to smile at her that evening.  And Peter turned more than once and smiled too.  But Honora did not consider Peter.  He was merely Providence in one of many disguises, and Providence is accepted by his beneficiaries as a matter of fact.

The rapture of a young lady of temperament is a difficult thing to picture.  The bird may feel it as he soars, on a bright August morning, high above amber cliffs jutting out into indigo seas; the novelist may feel it when the four walls of his room magically disappear and the profound secrets of the universe are on the point of revealing themselves.  Honora gazed, and listened, and lost herself.  She was no longer in Uhrig’s Cave, but in the great world, her soul a-quiver with harmonies.

“Pinafore,” although a comic opera, held something tragic for Honora, and opened the flood-gates to dizzy sensations which she did not understand.  How little Peter, who drummed on the table to the tune of: 

       “Give three cheers and one cheer more
        For the hearty captain of the Pinafore,”

imagined what was going on beside him!  There were two factors in his pleasure; he liked the music, and he enjoyed the delight of Honora.

What is Peter?  Let us cease looking at him through Honora’s eyes and taking him like daily bread, to be eaten and not thought about.  From one point of view, he is twenty-nine and elderly, with a sense of humour unsuspected by young persons of temperament.  Strive as we will, we have only been able to see him in his role of Providence, or of the piper.  Has he no existence, no purpose in life outside of that perpetual gentleman in waiting?  If so, Honora has never considered it.

After the finale had been sung and the curtain dropped for the last time, Honora sighed and walked out of the garden as one in a trance.  Once in a while, as he found a way for them through the crowd, Peter glanced down at her, and something like a smile tugged at the corners of a decidedly masculine mouth, and lit up his eyes.  Suddenly, at Locust Street, under the lamp, she stopped and surveyed him.  She saw