The effect of singing at a distance was produced by the curious fact that he was singing with his Bill closed, his darling scarlet throat puffed out and tremulous with the captive trills.

Perhaps a robin’s first song is always of this order.  I do not know.  I only know that this was his “earlier manner.”  My enraptured delight I expressed to him in my most eloquent phrases.  I praised him—­I flattered him.  I made him believe that no robin had really ever sung before.  He was much pleased and flew down on to the table to hear all about it and incite me to further effort.

In a few days he had learned to sing perfectly, not with the low distant-sounding note but with open beak and clear brilliant little roulades and trills.  He grew prouder and prouder.  When he saw I was busy he would tilt on a nearby bough and call me with flirtatious, provocative outbreaking of song.  He knew that it was impossible for any one to resist him—­any one in the world.  Of course I would get up and stand beneath his tree with my face upturned and tell him that his charm, his beauty, his fascination and my love were beyond the power of words to express.  He knew that would happen and revelled in it.  His tiny airs and graces, his devices to attract and absorb attention was unending.  He invented new ones every day and each was more enslaving than the last.

Could it be that he was guilty—­when he met other robins—­of boasting of his conquest of me and of my utter subjugation?  I cannot believe it possible.  Also I never saw other robins accost him or linger in their passage through the rose-garden to exchange civilities.  And yet a very strange thing occurred on one occasion.  I was sitting at my table expecting him and heard a familiar chirp.  When I looked up he was atilt upon the branch of an apple tree near by.  I greeted him with little whistles and twitters thinking of course that he would fly down to me for our usual conversation.  But though he chirped a reply and put his head on one side engagingly he did not move from his bough.

“What is the matter with you?” I said.  “Come down—­come down, little brother!”

But he did not come.  He only sidled and twittered and stayed where he was.  This was so extraordinary that I got up and went to him.  As I looked a curious doubt came upon me.  He looked like Tweetie—­(which had become his baptismal name) he tilted his head and flirted and twittered after the manner of Tweetie—­but—­could it be that he was not what he pretended to be?  Could he be a stranger bird?  That seemed out of the question as no stranger bird would have comported himself with such familiarity.  No stranger surely would have come so near and addressed me with such intimate twitterings and well-known airs and graces.  I was mystified beyond measure.  I exerted all my powers to lure him from his branch but descend from it he would not.  He listened and smiled and flirted his tail but he stayed where he was.