‘Well, Claude, you see I have the great Baron on my side.’

‘I am of the Baron’s opinion,’ said Claude, ’the only wonder is that you doubted it.’

‘You seemed to say that love was good for nothing.’

‘I said nothing but that Lily has a rhyme.’

’And saying that I was silly, was equivalent to saying that love was nothing,’ said Lily.

‘O Lily, I hope not,’ said Claude, with a comical air.

‘Well, I know I often am foolish, but not in this,’ said Lily; ’I do say that mere duty is not lovable.’

‘Say it if you will then,’ said Claude, yawning, ’only let me finish this sermon.’

Lily set herself to reconsider some of her lines:  but presently Emily left the room, Claude looked up, and Lily exclaimed, ’Now, Claude, let us make a trial of it.’

‘Well,’ said Claude, yawning again, and looking resigned.

’Think how Eleanor went on telling us of duty, duty, duty—­never making allowances—­never relaxing her stiff rules about trifles—­ never unbending from her duenna-like dignity—­never showing one spark of enthusiasm—­making great sacrifices, but only because she thought them her duty—­because it was right—­good for herself—­only a higher kind of selfishness—­not because her feeling prompted her.’

’Certainly, feeling does not usually prompt people to give up their lovers for the sake of their brothers and sisters.’

‘She did it because it was her duty,’ said Lily, ’quite as if she did not care.’

‘I wonder whether Frank thought so,’ said Claude.

’At any rate you will confess that Emily is a much more engaging person,’ said Lily.

‘Certainly, I had rather talk nonsense to her,’ said Claude.

‘You feel it, though you will not allow it,’ said Lily.  ’Now think of Emily’s sympathy, and gentleness, and sweet smile, and tell me if she is not a complete personification of love.  And then Eleanor, unpoetical—­never thrown off her balance by grief or joy, with no ups and downs—­no enthusiasm—­no appreciation of the beautiful—­her highest praise “very right,” and tell me if there can be a better image of duty.’

Claude might have had some chance of bringing Lily to her senses, if he had allowed that there was some truth in what she had said; but he thought the accusation so unjust in general, that he would not agree to any part of it, and only answered, ’You have very strange views of duty and of Eleanor.’

‘Well!’ replied Lily, ’I only ask you to watch; Emily and I are determined to act on the principle of love, and you will see if her government is not more successful than that of duty.’