William Mulligan was shipped out of the State on the steamer “Golden Age” on June 5th, 1856, with instructions never to return under penalty of death.  However, after three or four years of absence he returned to San Francisco.  He was often seen on the street, but was not molested until sometime in the summer of 1862 when he got a crowd of boys around him on the crossing of Prospect Place and Clay street, between Powell and Mason streets.  It was not long before he had trouble with them and shot into the crowd, injuring a boy, however, not seriously.  The police were soon on the ground, but Mulligan had made his way into the old St. Francis Hotel on the corner of Clay and Dupont streets which was vacant at that time.  The police came and they were directed to the building where Billy could be found.  When the police entered they found they were half a story below the floor of a very large room in the second story.  Billy was called upon to surrender.  He told them that the first one that put his head above the floor would be a dead man, and knowing the desperate character they were dealing with, they thought best to retire and get instruction from the City Attorney, who told them they had a right to take him dead or alive, whereupon they proceeded to arm themselves with rifles and stationed themselves on the second floor of a building on the opposite side of the street from the St. Francis on Dupont street, and when Mulligan was passing one of the windows the police fired.  Mulligan dropped to the floor, dead as a door nail.  He was turned over to the Coroner and has not been seen on the streets since.  Charles P. Duane is another one of twenty-seven men who were shipped out of the State and returned.  He shot a man named Ross on Merchant street, near Kearny.  I do not remember whether the man lived or died, or what became of Duane.

Black List.

From the book entitled “San Francisco Vigilance Committee of ’56,” by F. W. Smith, I quote the following, with some corrections and alterations: 

“I am informed by an ex-Vigilante that the Committee roll call of ’56, just before its disbandment, numbered between eight and nine thousand.

In concluding our history of this society, we will give the names and penalties inflicted on those who came under its eye during the latter year; whose conduct was so irreparably bad that it could not be excused.

Those who suffered the death penalty did so in expiation for lives they had taken.  The names of these culprits are familiar to the reader.  We also give the names of those who were required to leave the State; all of whom, in the archives of the Vigilantes, fall under the head of the black list:”