The island proved to be about twenty miles in length by seven in width.  It was uninhabited and there were no large animals on it.  It was Frank Merrill’s theory that it was the exposed peak of a huge extinct volcano.  In the center, filling the crater, was a little fresh-water lake.  The island was heavily wooded; but in contour it presented only diminutive contrasts of hill and valley.  And except as the semi-tropical foliage offered novelties of leaf and flower, the beauties of unfamiliar shapes and colors, it did not seem particularly interesting.  Ralph Addington was the guide of these expeditions.  From this tree, he pointed out, the South Sea Islander manufactured the tappa cloth, from that the poeepooee, from yonder the arva.  Honey Smith used to say that the only depressing thing about these trips was the utter silence of the gorgeous birds which they saw on every side.  On the other hand, they extracted what comfort they could from Merrill’s and Addington’s assurance that, should the ship’s supply give out, they could live comfortably enough on birds’ eggs, fruit, and fish.

Sorting what Honey Smith called the “ship-duffle” was one prolonged adventure.  At first they made little progress; for all five of them gathered over each important find, chattering like girls.  Each man followed the bent of his individual instinct for acquisitiveness.  Frank Merrill picked out books, paper, writing materials of every sort.  Ralph Addington ran to clothes.  The habit of the man with whom it is a business policy to appear well-dressed maintained itself; even in their Eveless Eden, he presented a certain tailored smartness.  Billy Fairfax selected kitchen utensils and tools.  Later, he came across a box filled with tennis rackets, nets, and balls.  The rackets’ strings had snapped and the balls were dead.  He began immediately to restring the rackets, to make new balls from twine, to lay out a court.  Like true soldiers of fortune, Honey Smith and Pete Murphy made no special collection; they looted for mere loot’s sake.

One day, in the midst of one of their raids, Honey Smith yelled a surprised and triumphant, “By jiminy!” The others showed no signs, of interest.  Honey was an alarmist; the treasure of the moment might prove to be a Japanese print or a corkscrew.  But as nobody stirred or spoke, he called, “The Wilmington ’Blue’!”

These words carried their inevitable magic.  His companions dropped everything; they swarmed about him.

Honey held on his palm what, in the brilliant sunlight looked like a globe of blue fire, a fire that emitted rainbows instead of sparks.

He passed it from hand to hand.  It seemed a miracle that the fingers which touched it did not burst into flame.  For a moment the five men might have been five children.

“Well,” said Pete Murphy, “according to all fiction precedent, the rest of us ought to get together immediately, if not a little sooner, and murder you, Honey.”