they left to the artists who succeeded them no other
glory than the hope of approaching these models, more
or less closely, by imitation, thus frustrating all
hope of ever equalling them, because the perfecting
of any process can never rival the merit of its invention.
The latter denied that the immaterial Beautiful could
have a fixed and absolute form. The different
forms which had appeared in the history of art, seemed
to them like tents spread in the interminable route
of the ideal; mere momentary halting places which
genius attains from epoch to epoch, and beyond which
the inheritors of the past should strive to advance.
The former wished to restrict the creations of times
and natures the most dissimilar, within the limits
of the same symmetrical frame; the latter claimed
for all writers the liberty of creating their own
mode, accepting no other rules than those which result
from the direct relation of sentiment and form, exacting
only that the form should be adequate to the expression
of the sentiment. However admirable the existing
models might be, they did not appear to them to have
exhausted all the range of sentiments upon which art
might seize, or all the forms which it might advantageously
use. Not contented with the mere excellence of
form, they sought it so far only as its perfection
is indispensable for the complete revelation of the
idea, for they were not ignorant that the sentiment
is maimed if the form remain imperfect, any imperfection
in it, like an opaque veil, intercepting the raying
of the pure idea. Thus they elevated what had
otherwise been the mere work of the trade, into the
sphere of poetic inspiration. They enjoined upon
genius and patience the task of inventing a form which
would satisfy the exactions of the inspiration.
They reproached their adversaries with attempting to
reduce inspiration to the bed of Procrustes, because
they refused to admit that there are sentiments which
cannot be expressed in forms which have been determined
upon beforehand, and of thus robbing art, in advance
even of their creation, of all works which might attempt
the introduction of newly awakened ideas, newly clad
in new forms; forms and ideas both naturally arising
from the naturally progressive development of the human
spirit, the improvement of the instruments, and the
consequent increase of the material resources of art.
Those who saw the flames of Genius devour the old worm-eaten crumbling skeletons, attached themselves to the musical school of which the most gifted, the most brilliant, the most daring representative, was Berlioz. Chopin joined this school. He persisted most strenuously in freeing himself from the servile formulas of conventional style, while he earnestly repudiated the charlatanism which sought to replace the old abuses only by the introduction of new ones.