etc.; nor from the probability of the evil increasing
after several generations, for on this latter head
I have not sufficient evidence, owing to the manner
in which my experiments were conducted. But if
plants bearing small and inconspicuous flowers were
not occasionally intercrossed, and did not profit
by the process, all their flowers would probably have
been rendered cleistogene, as they would thus have
largely benefited by having to produce only a small
quantity of safely-protected pollen. In coming
to this conclusion, I have been guided by the frequency
with which plants belonging to distinct orders have
been rendered cleistogene. But I can hear of no
instance of a species with all its flowers rendered
permanently cleistogene. Leersia makes the nearest
approach to this state; but as already stated, it has
been known to produce perfect flowers in one part of
Germany. Some other plants of the cleistogene
class, for instance Aspicarpa, have failed to produce
perfect flowers during several years in a hothouse;
but it does not follow that they would fail to do
so in their native country, any more than with Vandellia,
which with me produced only cleistogene flowers during
certain years. Plants belonging to this class
commonly bear both kinds of flowers every season,
and the perfect flowers of Viola canina yield fine
capsules, but only when visited by bees. We have
also seen that the seedlings of Ononis minutissima,
raised from the perfect flowers fertilised with pollen
from another plant, were finer than those from self-fertilised
flowers; and this was likewise the case to a certain
extent with Vandellia. As therefore no species
which at one time bore small and inconspicuous flowers
has had all its flowers rendered cleistogene, I must
believe that plants now bearing small and inconspicuous
flowers profit by their still remaining open, so as
to be occasionally intercrossed by insects. It
has been one of the greatest oversights in my work
that I did not experimentise on such flowers, owing
to the difficulty of fertilising them, and to my not
having seen the importance of the subject. (10/28.
Some of the species of Solanum would be good ones
for such experiments, for they are said by Hermann
Muller ‘Befruchtung’ page 434, to be unattractive
to insects from not secreting nectar, not producing
much pollen, and not being very conspicuous.
Hence probably it is that, according to Verlot ’Production
des Varieties’ 1865 page 72, the varieties of
“les aubergines et les tomates” (species
of Solanum) do not intercross when they are cultivated
near together; but it should be remembered that these
are not endemic species. On the other hand, the
flowers of the common potato (S. tuberosum), though
they do not secrete nectar Kurr ’Bedeutung der
Nektarien’ 1833 page 40, yet cannot be considered
as inconspicuous, and they are sometimes visited by
diptera (Muller), and, as I have seen, by humble-bees.
Tinzmann (as quoted in ‘Gardeners’ Chronicle’
1846 page 183, found that some of the varieties did
not bear seed when fertilised with pollen from the
same variety, but were fertile with that from another
variety.)