this circumstance, coupled with the constant and seemingly
peevish opposition which he gave to almost all Argyle’s
plans, a suspicion has arisen that he had been treacherous
throughout. But the account given of his pardon
by Burnet, who says his father, Lord Dundonald, who
was an opulent nobleman, purchased it with a considerable
sum of money, is more credible, as well as more candid;
and it must be remembered that in Sir John’s
disputes with his general, he was almost always acting
in conjunction with Sir Patrick Hume, who is proved,
by the subsequent events, and indeed by the whole
tenor of his life and conduct, to have been uniformly
sincere and zealous in the cause of his country.
Cochrane was sent to England, where he had an interview
with the king, and gave such answers to the questions
put to him as were deemed satisfactory by his majesty;
and the information thus obtained whatever might be
the real and secret causes, furnished a plausible
pretence at least for the exercise of royal mercy.
Sir Patrick Hume, after having concealed himself
some time in the house, and under the protection of
Lady Eleanor Dunbar, sister to the Earl of Eglington,
found means to escape to Holland, whence he returned
in better times, and was created first Lord Hume of
Polwarth, and afterwards Earl of Marchmont.
Fullarton, and Campbell of Auchinbreak, appear to
have escaped, but by what means is not known.
Two sons of Argyle, John and Charles, and Archibald
Campbell, his nephew, were sentenced to death and
forfeiture, but the capital part of the sentence was
remitted. Thomas Archer, a clergyman, who had
been wounded at Muirdyke, was executed, notwithstanding
many applications in his favour, among which was one
from Lord Drumlanrig, Queensbury’s eldest son.
Woodrow, who was himself a Presbyterian minister,
and though a most valuable and correct historian,
was not without a tincture of the prejudices belonging
to his order, attributes the unrelenting spirit of
the government in this instance to their malice against
the clergy of his sect. Some of the holy ministry,
he observes, as Guthrie at the restoration, Kidd and
Mackail after the insurrections at Pentland and Bothwell
Bridge, and now Archer, were upon every occasion to
be sacrificed to the fury of the persecutors.
But to him who is well acquainted with the history
of this period, the habitual cruelty of the government
will fully account for any particular act of severity;
and it is only in cases of lenity, such as that of
Cochrane, for instance, that he will look for some
hidden or special motive.
Ayloff, having in vain attempted to kill himself, was, like Cochrane, sent to London to be examined. His relationship to the king’s first wife might perhaps be one inducement to this measure, or it might be thought more expedient that he should be executed for the Rye House Plot, the credit of which it was a favourite object of the court to uphold, than for his recent acts of rebellion in Scotland. Upon