when the Reform League orators inveigh against our
cruel and bloated aristocracy, these invectives so
evidently show the passions and point of view of the
Populace, that they do not sink into the minds of those
at whom they are addressed, or awaken any thought
or self-examination in them. Again, when Sir
Thomas Bateson describes the Philistines and the Populace
as influenced with a kind of hideous mania for emasculating
the aristocracy, that reproach so clearly comes from
the wrath and excited imagination of the Barbarians,
that it does not much set the Philistines and the
Populace thinking. Or when Mr. Lowe calls the
Populace drunken and venal, he [121] so evidently calls
them this in an agony of apprehension for his Philistine
or middle-class Parliament, which has done so many
great and heroic works, and is now threatened with
mixture and debasement, that the Populace do not lay
his words seriously to heart. So the voice which
makes a permanent impression on each of our classes
is the voice of its friends, and this is from the
nature of things, as I have said, a comforting voice.
The Barbarians remain in the belief that the great
broad-shouldered genial Englishman may be well satisfied
with himself; the Philistines remain in the belief
that the great middle-class of this country, with
its earnest common-sense penetrating through sophisms
and ignoring commonplaces, may be well satisfied with
itself: the Populace, that the working-man with
his bright powers of sympathy and ready powers of
action, may be well satisfied with himself. What
hope, at this rate, of extinguishing the taste of the
bathos implanted by nature itself in the soul of man,
or of inculcating the belief that excellence dwells
among high and steep rocks, and can only be reached
by those who sweat blood to reach her? But it
will be said, perhaps, that candidates for [122] political
influence and leadership, who thus caress the self-love
of those whose suffrages they desire, know quite well
that they are not saying the sheer truth as reason
sees it, but that they are using a sort of conventional
language, or what we call clap-trap, which is essential
to the working of representative institutions.
And therefore, I suppose, we ought rather to say
with Figaro: Qui est-ce qu’on trompe ici?+
Now, I admit that often, but not always, when our
governors say smooth things to the self-love of the
class whose political support they want, they know
very well that they are overstepping, by a long stride,
the bounds of truth and soberness; and while they talk,
they in a manner, no doubt, put their tongue in their
cheek. Not always; because, when a Barbarian
appeals to his own class to make him their representative
and give him political power, he, when he pleases
their self-love by extolling broad-shouldered genial
Englishmen with their sense of duty, reverence for
the laws, and patient force, pleases his own self-love
and extols himself, and is, therefore, himself ensnared
by his own smooth words. And so, too, when a