The mistress did not allow Cayrol to finish his sentence; she rang the bell and asked for her daughter.  This time, Cayrol prudently took the opportunity of disappearing.  He had opened fire; it was for Micheline to decide the result of the battle.  The banker awaited the issue of the interview between mother and daughter in the next room.  Through the door he heard the irritated tones of Madame Desvarennes, to which Micheline answered softly and slowly.  The mother threatened and stormed.  Coldly and quietly the daughter received the attack.  The tussle lasted about an hour, when the door reopened and Madame Desvarennes appeared, pale and still trembling, but calmed.  Micheline, wiping her beautiful eyes, still wet with tears, regained her apartment.

“Well,” said Cayrol timidly, seeing the mistress standing silent and absorbed before him; “I see with pleasure that you are less agitated.  Did Mademoiselle Micheline give you good reasons?”

“Good reasons!” cried Madame Desvarennes with a violent gesture, last flash of the late storm.  “She cried, that’s all.  And you know when she cries I no longer know what I do or say!  She breaks my heart with her tears.  And she knows it.  Ah! it is a great misfortune to love children too much!”

This energetic woman was conquered, and yet understood that she was wrong to allow herself to be conquered.  She fell into a deep reverie, and forgot that Cayrol was present.  She thought of the future which she had planned for Micheline, and which the latter carelessly destroyed in an instant.

Pierre, now an orphan, would have been a real son to the mistress.  He would have lived in her house, and have surrounded her old age with care and affection.  And then, he was so full of ability that he could not help attaining a brilliant position.  She would have helped him, and would have rejoiced in his success.  And all this scaffolding was overturned because this Panine had crossed Micheline’s path.  A foreign adventurer, prince perhaps, but who could tell?  Lies are easily told when the proofs of the lie have to be sought beyond the frontiers.  And it was her daughter who was going to fall in love with an insipid fop who only coveted her millions.  That she should see such a man enter her family, steal Micheline’s love from her, and rummage her strongbox!  In a moment she vowed mortal hatred against Panine, and resolved to do all she could to prevent the longed-for marriage with her daughter.

She was disturbed in her meditation by Cayrol’s voice.  He wished to take an answer to the Prince.  What must he say to him?

“You will let him know,” said Madame Desvarennes, “that he must refrain from seeking opportunities of meeting my daughter.  If he be a gentleman, he will understand that his presence, even in Paris, is disagreeable to me.  I ask him to go away for three weeks.  After that time he may come back, and I agree to give him an answer.”