“Oh, I don’t, judge, I don’t!” Bittridge interposed.  “All I want is to be able to tell my mother—­I don’t care for anybody else—­that I saw you, and you allowed me to say that I was truly sorry for the pain—­if it was pain; or annoyance, anyway—­that I had caused you, and to go back to her with the hope of atoning for it sometime or somehow.  That’s all.”

“Look here!” cried Renton.  “What have you written to my daughter for?”

“Wasn’t that natural?  I prized her esteem more than I do yours even; but did I ask her anything more than I’ve asked you?  I didn’t expect her to answer me; all I wanted was to have her believe that I wasn’t as black as I was painted—­not inside, anyway.  You know well enough—­anybody knows —­that I would rather have her think well of me than any one else in this world, except my mother.  I haven’t got the gift of showing out what’s good in me, if there is any good, but I believe Miss Ellen would want to think well of me if I gave her a chance.  If ever there was an angel on earth, she’s one.  I don’t deny that I was hopeful of mercy from her, because she can’t think evil, but I can lay my hand on my heart and say that I wasn’t selfish in my hopes.  It seemed to me that it was her due to understand that a man whom she had allowed to be her friend wasn’t altogether unworthy.  That’s as near as I can come to putting into words the motive I had in writing to her.  I can’t even begin to put into words the feeling I have towards her.  It’s as if she was something sacred.”

This was the feeling Renton himself had towards his daughter, and for the first time he found himself on common ground with the scapegrace who professed it, and whose light, mocking face so little enforced his profession.  If Bittridge could have spoken in the dark, his words might have carried a conviction of his sincerity, but there, in plain day, confronting the father of Ellen, who had every wish to believe him true, the effect was different.  Deep within his wish to think the man honest, Kenton recoiled from him.  He vaguely perceived that it was because she could not think evil that this wretch had power upon her, and he was sensible, as he had not been before, that she had no safety from him except in absence.  He did not know what to answer; he could not repel him in open terms, and still less could he meet him with any words that would allow him to resume his former relations with his family.  He said, finally:  “We will let matters stand.  We are going to Europe in a week, and I shall not see you again.  I will tell Mrs. Kenton what you say.”

“Thank you, judge.  And tell her that I appreciate your kindness more than I can say!” The judge rose from his chair and went towards the window, which he had thrown open.  “Going to shut up?  Let me help you with that window; it seems to stick.  Everything fast up-stairs?”

“I—­I think so,” Kenton hesitated.