way that it was like the pair of pantaloons the Yankee
pedlar offered for sale, “large enough for any
man, small enough for any boy.” They therefore
had taken a position calculated to break down their
single important declared object. They were working
for the election of either Gen. Cass or Gen. Taylor.
The speaker then went on to show, clearly and eloquently,
the danger of extension of slavery, likely to result
from the election of Gen. Cass. To unite with
those who annexed the new territory to prevent the
extension of slavery in that territory seemed to him
to be in the highest degree absurd and ridiculous.
Suppose these gentlemen succeed in electing Mr. Van
Buren, they had no specific means to prevent the extension
of slavery to New Mexico and California, and Gen.
Taylor, he confidently believed, would not encourage
it, and would not prohibit its restriction. But
if Gen. Cass was elected, he felt certain that the
plans of farther extension of territory would be encouraged,
and those of the extension of slavery would meet no
check. The “Free Soil” mart in claiming
that name indirectly attempts a deception, by implying
that Whigs were not Free Soil men. Declaring
that they would “do their duty and leave the
consequences to God” merely gave an excuse for
taking a course they were not able to maintain by
a fair and full argument. To make this declaration
did not show what their duty was. If it did we
should have no use for judgment, we might as well
be made without intellect; and when divine or human
law does not clearly point out what is our duty, we
have no means of finding out what it is but by using
our most intelligent judgment of the consequences.
If there were divine law or human law for voting for
Martin Van Buren, or if a, fair examination of the
consequences and just reasoning would show that voting
for him would bring about the ends they pretended
to wish—then he would give up the argument.
But since there was no fixed law on the subject, and
since the whole probable result of their action would
be an assistance in electing Gen. Cass, he must say
that they were behind the Whigs in their advocacy
of the freedom of the soil.
Mr. Lincoln proceeded to rally the Buffalo convention
for forbearing to say anything—after all
the previous declarations of those members who were
formerly Whigs—on the subject of the Mexican
War, because the Van Burens had been known to have
supported it. He declared that of all the parties
asking the confidence of the country, this new one
had less of principle than any other.
He wondered whether it was still the opinion of these
Free Soil gentlemen, as declared in the “whereas”
at Buffalo, that the Whig and Democratic parties were
both entirely dissolved and absorbed into their own
body. Had the Vermont election given them any
light? They had calculated on making as great
an impression in that State as in any part of the
Union, and there their attempts had been wholly ineffectual.
Their failure was a greater success than they would
find in any other part of the Union.