I am silent for a good while.  I am trying to think who I am.  There was a person whom I thought I knew, very fond of Herbert, and agreeing with him in most things.  Where has he gone? and, if he is here, where is the Herbert that I knew?

If his intellectual and moral sympathies have all changed, I wonder if his physical tastes remain, like his appearance, the same.  There has come over this country within the last generation, as everybody knows, a great wave of condemnation of pie.  It has taken the character of a “movement!” though we have had no conventions about it, nor is any one, of any of the several sexes among us, running for president against it.  It is safe almost anywhere to denounce pie, yet nearly everybody eats it on occasion.  A great many people think it savors of a life abroad to speak with horror of pie, although they were very likely the foremost of the Americans in Paris who used to speak with more enthusiasm of the American pie at Madame Busque’s than of the Venus of Milo.  To talk against pie and still eat it is snobbish, of course; but snobbery, being an aspiring failing, is sometimes the prophecy of better things.  To affect dislike of pie is something.  We have no statistics on the subject, and cannot tell whether it is gaining or losing in the country at large.  Its disappearance in select circles is no test.  The amount of writing against it is no more test of its desuetude, than the number of religious tracts distributed in a given district is a criterion of its piety.  We are apt to assume that certain regions are substantially free of it.  Herbert and I, traveling north one summer, fancied that we could draw in New England a sort of diet line, like the sweeping curves on the isothermal charts, which should show at least the leading pie sections.  Journeying towards the White Mountains, we concluded that a line passing through Bellows Falls, and bending a little south on either side, would mark northward the region of perpetual pie.  In this region pie is to be found at all hours and seasons, and at every meal.  I am not sure, however, that pie is not a matter of altitude rather than latitude, as I find that all the hill and country towns of New England are full of those excellent women, the very salt of the housekeeping earth, who would feel ready to sink in mortification through their scoured kitchen floors, if visitors should catch them without a pie in the house.  The absence of pie would be more noticed than a scarcity of Bible even.  Without it the housekeepers are as distracted as the boarding-house keeper, who declared that if it were not for canned tomato, she should have nothing to fly to.  Well, in all this great agitation I find Herbert unmoved, a conservative, even to the under-crust.  I dare not ask him if he eats pie at breakfast.  There are some tests that the dearest friendship may not apply.

“Will you smoke?” I ask.

“No, I have reformed.”

“Yes, of course.”