Again, the argument of the Boers would be more valid had they received no benefit from these immigrants.  If they had ignored them they might fairly have stated that they did not desire their presence.  But even while they protested they grew rich at the Uitlander’s expense.  They could not have it both ways.  It would be consistent to discourage him and not profit by him, or to make him comfortable and build the State upon his money; but to ill-treat him and at the same time to grow strong by his taxation must surely be an injustice.

And again, the whole argument is based upon the narrow racial supposition that every naturalised citizen not of Boer extraction must necessarily be unpatriotic.  This is not borne out by the examples of history.  The newcomer soon becomes as proud of his country and as jealous of her liberty as the old.  Had President Kruger given the franchise generously to the Uitlander, his pyramid would have been firm upon its base and not balanced upon its apex.  It is true that the corrupt oligarchy would have vanished, and the spirit of a broader more tolerant freedom influenced the counsels of the State.  But the republic would have become stronger and more permanent, with a population who, if they differed in details, were united in essentials.  Whether such a solution would have been to the advantage of British interests in South Africa is quite another question.  In more ways than one President Kruger has been a good friend to the empire.

So much upon the general question of the reason why the Uitlander should agitate and why the Boer was obdurate.  The details of the long struggle between the seekers for the franchise and the refusers of it may be quickly sketched, but they cannot be entirely ignored by any one who desires to understand the inception of that great contest which was the outcome of the dispute.

At the time of the Convention of Pretoria (1881) the rights of burghership might be obtained by one year’s residence.  In 1882 it was raised to five years, the reasonable limit which obtains both in Great Britain and in the United States.  Had it remained so, it is safe to say that there would never have been either an Uitlander question or a great Boer war.  Grievances would have been righted from the inside without external interference.

In 1890 the inrush of outsiders alarmed the Boers, and the franchise was raised so as to be only attainable by those who had lived fourteen years in the country.  The Uitlanders, who were increasing rapidly in numbers and were suffering from the formidable list of grievances already enumerated, perceived that their wrongs were so numerous that it was hopeless to have them set right seriatim, and that only by obtaining the leverage of the franchise could they hope to move the heavy burden which weighed them down.  In 1893 a petition of 13,000 Uitlanders, couched in most respectful terms, was submitted to the Raad, but met with contemptuous