“Ah, Mr. Traill, I’m afraid you’re a sad, irreverent young dog yourself, sir.”  The minister broke into a genial laugh.  “Man, you’ve spoiled a bit of fun I was having with Mr. Brown, who takes his duties ‘sairiously."’ He sat looking down at the little dog until Bobby came up to him and stood confidingly under his caressing hand.  Then he added:  “I have suspected for some months that he was living in the churchyard.  It is truly remarkable that an active, noisy little Skye could keep so still about it.”

At that Mr. Brown retreated to the martyrs’ monument to meditate on the unministerial behavior of this minister and professor of Biblical criticism in the University.  Mr. Traill, however, sat himself down on the slab for a pleasant probing into the soul of this courageous dominie, who had long been under fire for his innovations in the kirk services.

“I heard of Bobby first early in the winter, from a Bible-reader at the Medical Mission in the Cowgate, who saw the little dog’s master buried.  He sees many strange, sad things in his work, but nothing ever shocked him so as the lonely death of that pious old shepherd in such a picturesque den of vice and misery.”

“Ay, he went from my place, fair ill, into the storm.  I never knew whaur the auld man died.”

The minister looked at Mr. Traill, struck by the note of remorse in his tone.

“The missionary returned to the churchyard to look for the dog that had refused to leave the grave.  He concluded that Bobby had gone away to a new home and master, as most dogs do go sooner or later.  Some weeks afterward the minister of a small church in the hills inquired for him and insisted that he was still here.  This last week, at the General Assembly, I heard of the wee Highlander from several sources.  The tales of his escapes from the sheep-farm have grown into a sort of Odyssey of the Pentlands.  I think, perhaps, if you had not continued to feed him, Mr. Traill, he might have remained at his old home.”

“Nae, I’m no’ thinking so, and I was no’ willing to risk the starvation of the bonny, leal Highlander.”

Until the stars came out Mr. Traill sat there telling the story.  At mention of his master’s name Bobby returned to the mound and stretched himself across it.  “I will go before the kirk officers, Doctor Lee, and tak’ full responseebility.  Mr. Brown is no’ to blame.  It would have tak’n a man with a heart of trap-rock to have turned the woeful bit dog out.”

“He is well cared for and is of a hardy breed, so he is not likely to suffer; but a dog, no more than a man, cannot live on bread alone.  His heart hungers for love.”

“Losh!” cried Mr. Brown.  “Are ye thinkin’ he isna gettin’ it?  Oor bairns are a’ oot o’ the hame nest, an’ ma woman, Jeanie, is fair daft aboot Bobby, aye thinkin’ he’ll tak’ the measles.  An’ syne, there’s a’ the tenement bairns cryin’ oot on ‘im ilka meenit, an’ ane crippled laddie he een lets fondle ’im.”