At that the church officers threw up their hands.  They preferred to sound public sentiment themselves, and would consider it.  But if Bobby was permitted to be buried with his master there must be no notice taken of it.  Well, the Heriot laddies might line up along the wall, and the tenement bairns look down from the windows.  Would that satisfy her ladyship?

“As far as it goes.”  The Grand Leddy was smiling, but a little tremulous about the mouth.

That was a day when women had little to say in public, and she meant to make a speech, and to ask to be allowed to do an unheard-of thing.

“I want to put up a monument to the nameless man who inspired such love, and to the little dog that was capable of giving it.  Ah gentlemen, do not refuse, now.”  She sketched her idea of the classic fireplace bier, the dead shepherd of the Pentlands, and the little prostrate terrier.  “Immemorial man and his faithful dog.  Our society for the prevention of cruelty to animals is finding it so hard to get people even to admit the sacredness of life in dumb creatures, the brutalizing effects of abuse of them on human beings, and the moral and practical worth to us of kindness.  To insist that a dog feels, that he loves devotedly and with less calculation than men, that he grieves at a master’s death and remembers him long years, brings a smile of amusement.  Ah yes!  Here in Scotland, too, where your own great Lord Erskine was a pioneer of pity two generations ago, and with Sir Walter’s dogs beloved of the literary, and Doctor Brown’s immortal ‘Rab,’ we find it uphill work.

“The story of Greyfriars Bobby is quite the most complete and remarkable ever recorded in dog annals.  His lifetime of devotion has been witnessed by thousands, and honored publicly, by your own Lord Provost, with the freedom of the city, a thing that, I believe, has no precedent.  All the endearing qualities of the dog reach their height in this loyal and lovable Highland terrier; and he seems to have brought out the best qualities of the people who have known him.  Indeed, for fourteen years hundreds of disinherited children have been made kinder and happier by knowing Bobby’s story and having that little dog to love.”

She stopped in some embarrassment, seeing how she had let herself go, in this warm championship, and then she added: 

“Bobby does not need a monument, but I think we need one of him, that future generations may never forget what the love of a dog may mean, to himself and to us.”

The Grand Leddy must have won her plea, then and there, but for the fact that the matter of erecting a monument of a public character anywhere in the city had to come up before the Burgh council.  In that body the stubborn opposition of a few members unexpectedly developed, and, in spite of popular sympathy with the proposal, the plan was rejected.  Permission was given, however, for Lady Burdett-Coutts to put up a suitable memorial to Bobby at the end of George IV Bridge, and opposite the main gateway to the kirkyard.