In the succeeding debates, then, various opinions were given with regard to the place to be selected for the Emperor’s sepulture.  “Some demanded,” says an eloquent anonymous Captain in the Navy who has written an “Itinerary from Toulon to St. Helena,” “that the coffin should be deposited under the bronze taken from the enemy by the French army—­under the Column of the Place Vendome.  The idea was a fine one.  This is the most glorious monument that was ever raised in a conqueror’s honor.  This column has been melted out of foreign cannon.  These same cannons have furrowed the bosoms of our braves with noble cicatrices; and this metal—­conquered by the soldier first, by the artist afterwards—­has allowed to be imprinted on its front its own defeat and our glory.  Napoleon might sleep in peace under this audacious trophy.  But, would his ashes find a shelter sufficiently vast beneath this pedestal?  And his puissant statue dominating Paris, beams with sufficient grandeur on this place:  whereas the wheels of carriages and the feet of passengers would profane the funereal sanctity of the spot in trampling on the soil so near his head.”

You must not take this description, dearest Amelia, “at the foot of the letter,” as the French phrase it, but you will here have a masterly exposition of the arguments for and against the burial of the Emperor under the Column of the Place Vendome.  The idea was a fine one, granted; but, like all other ideas, it was open to objections.  You must not fancy that the cannon, or rather the cannon-balls, were in the habit of furrowing the bosoms of French braves, or any other braves, with cicatrices:  on the contrary, it is a known fact that cannon-balls make wounds, and not cicatrices (which, my dear, are wounds partially healed); nay, that a man generally dies after receiving one such projectile on his chest, much more after having his bosom furrowed by a score of them.  No, my love; no bosom, however heroic, can stand such applications, and the author only means that the French soldiers faced the cannon and took them.  Nor, my love, must you suppose that the column was melted:  it was the cannon was melted, not the column; but such phrases are often used by orators when they wish to give a particular force and emphasis to their opinions.

Well, again, although Napoleon might have slept in peace under “this audacious trophy,” how could he do so and carriages go rattling by all night, and people with great iron heels to their boots pass clattering over the stones?  Nor indeed could it be expected that a man whose reputation stretches from the Pyramids to the Kremlin, should find a column of which the base is only five-and-twenty feet square, a shelter vast enough for his bones.  In a word, then, although the proposal to bury Napoleon under the column was ingenious, it was found not to suit; whereupon somebody else proposed the Madelaine.