Dunstan’s, and there prayed for King William and Queen Mary.  The apostolical injunction, he said, was that prayers should be made for all in authority, and William and Mary were visibly in authority.  His Jacobite friends loudly blamed his inconsistency.  How, they asked, if you admit that the Apostle speaks in this passage of actual authority, can you maintain that, in other passages of a similar kind, he speaks only of legitimate authority?  Or how can you, without sin, designate as King, in a solemn address to God, one whom you cannot, without sin, promise to obey as King?  These reasonings were unanswerable; and Sherlock soon began to think them so; but the conclusion to which they led him was diametrically opposed to the conclusion to which they were meant to lead him.  He hesitated, however, till a new light flashed on his mind from a quarter from which there was little reason to expect any thing but tenfold darkness.  In the reign of James the First, Doctor John Overall, Bishop of Exeter, had written an elaborate treatise on the rights of civil and ecclesiastical governors.  This treatise had been solemnly approved by the Convocations of Canterbury and York, and might therefore be considered as an authoritative exposition of the doctrine of the Church of England.  A copy of the manuscript was in Sancroft’s possession; and he, soon after the Revolution, sent it to the press.  He hoped, doubtless, that the publication would injure the new government; but he was lamentably disappointed.  The book indeed condemned all resistance in terms as strong as he could himself have used; but one passage which had escaped his notice was decisive against himself and his fellow schismatics.  Overall, and the two Convocations which had given their sanction to Overall’s teaching, pronounced that a government, which had originated in rebellion, ought, when thoroughly settled, to be considered as ordained by God and to be obeyed by Christian men.60 Sherlock read, and was convinced.  His venerable mother the Church had spoken; and he, with the docility of a child, accepted her decree.  The government which had sprung from the Revolution might, at least since the battle of the Boyne and the flight of James from Ireland, be fairly called a settled government, and ought therefore to be passively obeyed till it should be subverted by another revolution and succeeded by another settled government.

Sherlock took the oaths, and speedily published, in justification of his conduct, a pamphlet entitled The Case of Allegiance to Sovereign Powers stated.  The sensation produced by this work was immense.  Dryden’s Hind and Panther had not raised so great an uproar.  Halifax’s Letter to a Dissenter had not called forth so many answers.  The replies to the Doctor, the vindications of the Doctor, the pasquinades on the Doctor, would fill a library.  The clamour redoubled when it was known that the convert had not only been reappointed Master of the Temple, but had accepted the Deanery of Saint Paul’s,