is simply a repeated achievement and a happy accident.
If such happens to be the case with the coarse woof
and canvas, with the large and approximately strong
threads of our intellect, what are the chances for
the ulterior and superadded embroidery, the subtle
and complicated netting forming reason properly so
called, and which is composed of general ideas?
Formed by a slow and delicate process of weaving,
through a long system of signs, amidst the agitation
of pride, of enthusiasm and of dogmatic obstinacy,
what risk, even in the most perfect brain, for these
ideas only inadequately to correspond with outward
reality! All that we require in this connection
is to witness the operation of the idyll in vogue
with the philosophers and politicians. — These
being the superior minds, what can be said of the
masses of the people, of the uncultivated or semi-cultivated
brains? According as reason is crippled in man
so is it rare in humanity. General ideas and
accurate reasoning are found only in a select few.
The comprehension of abstract terms and the habit
of making accurate deductions requires previous and
special preparation, a prolonged mental exercise and
steady practice, and besides this, where political
matters are concerned, a degree of composure which,
affording every facility for reflection, enables a
man to detach himself for a moment from himself for
the consideration of his interests as a disinterested
observer. If one of these conditions is wanting,
reason, especially in relation to politics, is absent.
— In a peasant or a villager, in any man brought
up from infancy to manual labor, not only is the network
of superior conceptions defective, but again the internal
machinery by which they are woven is not perfected.
Accustomed to the open air, to the exercise of his
limbs, his attention flags if he stands inactive for
a quarter of an hour; generalized expressions find
their way into his mind only as sound; the mental
combination they ought to excite cannot be produced.
He becomes drowsy unless a powerful vibrating voice
contagiously arouses in him the instincts of flesh
and blood, the personal cravings, the secret enmities
which, restrained by outward discipline, are always
ready to be set free. — In the half-cultivated
mind, even with the man who thinks himself cultivated
and who reads the newspapers, principles are generally
disproportionate guests; they are above his comprehension;
he does not measure their bearings, he does not appreciate
their limitations, he is insensible to their restrictions
and he falsifies their application. They are
like those preparations of the laboratory which, harmless
in the chemist’s hands, become destructive in
the street under the feet of passing people. —
Too soon will this be apparent when, in the name of
popular sovereignty, each commune, each mob, shall
regard itself as the nation and act accordingly; when
Reason, in the hands of its new interpreters, shall
inaugurate riots in the streets and peasant insurrections
in the fields.[15]