One day, in the end of September, Mr. Arnold and Hugh were alone after breakfast.  Mr. Arnold spoke: 

“Mr. Sutherland, I have altered my plans with regard to Harry.  I wish him to spend the winter in London.”

Hugh listened and waited.  Mr. Arnold went on, after a slight pause: 

“There I wish him to reap such advantages as are to be gained in the metropolis.  He has improved wonderfully under your instruction; and is now, I think, to be benefited principally by a variety of teachers.  I therefore intend that he shall have masters for the different branches which it is desirable he should study.  Consequently I shall be compelled to deny him your services, valuable as they have hitherto been.”

“Very well, Mr. Arnold,” said Mr. Sutherland, with the indifference of one who feels himself ill-used.  “When shall I take my leave of him?”

“Not before the middle of the next month, at the earliest.  But I will write you a cheque for your salary at once.”

So saying, Mr. Arnold left the room for a moment, and returning, handed Hugh a cheque for a year’s salary.  Hugh glanced at it, and offering it again to Mr. Arnold, said: 

“No, Mr. Arnold; I can claim scarcely more than half a year’s salary.”

“Mr. Sutherland, your engagement was at so much a year; and if I prevent you from fulfilling your part of it, I am bound to fulfil mine.  Indeed, you might claim further provision.”

“You are very kind, Mr. Arnold.”

“Only just,” rejoined Mr. Arnold, with conscious dignity.  “I am under great obligation to you for the way in which you have devoted yourself to Harry.”

Hugh’s conscience gave him a pang.  Is anything more painful than undeserved praise?

“I have hardly done my duty by him,” said he.

“I can only say that the boy is wonderfully altered for the better, and I thank you.  I am obliged to you:  oblige me by putting the cheque in your pocket.”

Hugh persisted no longer in his refusal; and indeed it had been far more a feeling of pride than of justice that made him decline accepting it at first.  Nor was there any generosity in Mr. Arnold’s cheque; for Hugh, as he admitted, might have claimed board and lodging as well.  But Mr. Arnold was one of the ordinarily honourable, who, with perfect characters for uprightness, always contrive to err on the safe side of the purse, and the doubtful side of a severely interpreted obligation.  Such people, in so doing, not unfrequently secure for themselves, at the same time, the reputation of generosity.

Hugh could not doubt that his dismissal was somehow or other connected with the loss of the ring; but he would not stoop to inquire into the matter.  He hoped that time would set all right; and, in fact, felt considerable indifference to the opinion of Mr. Arnold, or of any one in the house, except Harry.