Duelling is a form of murder and suicide combined, for which there can possibly be no justification.  The code of honor that requires the reparation of an insult at the point of the sword or the muzzle of a pistol has no existence outside the befogged intelligence of godless men.  The duel repairs nothing and aggravates the evil it seeks to remedy.  The justice it appeals to is a creature dependent on skill and luck; such justice is not only blind, but crazy as well.

That is why the Church anathematizes duelling.  The duel she condemns is a hand-to-hand combat prearranged as to weapons, time and place, and it is immaterial whether it be to the death or only to the letting of first blood.  She fulminates her major excommunication against duellists, even in the event of their failing to keep their agreement.  Her sentence affects seconds and all those who advise or favor or abet, and even those whose simple presence is an incentive and encouragement.  She refuses Christian burial to the one who falls, unless before dying he shows certain dispositions of repentance.

Prize fighting, however brutal and degrading, must not be put in the category of duelling.  Its object is not to wipe out an insult, but to furnish sport and to reap the incidental profits.  In normal conditions there is no danger to life or limb.  Sharkey might stop with the point of his chin a blow that would send many another into kingdom come; but so long as Sharkey does the stopping the danger remains non-existent.  If, however, hate instead of lucre bring the men together, that motive would be sufficient to make the game one of blood if not of death.

Lynching, is another kind of murder, and a cowardly, brutal kind, at that.  No crime, no abomination on the part of the victim, however great, can justify such an inhuman proceeding.  It brands with the crime of wilful murder every man or woman who has a hand in it.  To defend the theory of lynching-is as bad as to carry it out in practice.  And it is greatly to be feared that the Almighty will one day call this land to account for the outrageous performances of unbridled license and heartless cruelty that occur so frequently in our midst.

The only plea on which to ground an excuse for such exhibitions of brutality and disrespect for order and justice would be the inability of established government to mete out justice to the guilty; but this is not even the case, for government is defied and lawful authority capable and willing to punish is spurned; the culprit is taken from the hands of the law and delivered over to the vengeance of a mob.  However popular the doctrine of Judge Lynch may be in certain sections of the land, it is nevertheless reprobated by the law of God and stands condemned at the bar of His justice.

CHAPTER LXXII.  ON THE ETHICS OF WAR.