not at that time pass through any part of the city,
lest some one should say, ‘See, where goes that
fool!’ The syndics and others forming the assembly
remained confounded, first, by the difficult methods
proposed by the other masters, and next by that of
Filippo, which appeared to them stark nonsense.
He appeared to them to render the enterprise impossible
by his two propositions—first, by that of
making the cupola double, whereby the great weight
to be sustained would be rendered altogether unmanageable,
and next by the proposal of building without a framework.
Filippo, on the other hand, who had spent so many
years in close study to prepare himself for this work,
knew not to what course to betake himself, and was
many times on the point of leaving Florence.
Still, if he desired to conquer, it was necessary to
arm himself with patience, and he had seen enough
to know that the heads of the city seldom remained
long fixed to one resolution. He might easily
have shown them a small model which he had secretly
made, but he would not do so, knowing the imperfect
intelligence of the syndics, the envy of the artists,
and the instability of the citizens, who favored now
one and now another, as each chanced to please them.
And I do not wonder at this, because every one in
Florence professes to know as much of these matters,
as do the most experienced masters, although there
are very few who really understand them; a truth which
we may be permitted to affirm without offence to those
who are well informed on the subject. What Filippo
therefore could not effect before the tribunal, he
began to attempt with individuals, and talking apart
now with a syndic, now with a warden, and again with
different citizens, showing moreover certain parts
of his design; he thus brought them at length to resolve
on confiding the conduct of this work, either to him
or to one of the foreign architects. Hereupon,
the syndics, the wardens, and the citizens, selected
to be judges in the matter, having regained courage,
gathered together once again, and the architects disputed
respecting the matter before them; but all were put
down and vanquished on sufficient grounds by Filippo,
and here it is said that the dispute of the egg arose,
in the manner following. The other architects
desired that Filippo should explain his purpose minutely,
and show his model, as they had shown theirs.
This he would not do, but proposed to all the masters,
foreigners and compatriots, that he who could make
an egg stand upright on a piece of smooth marble,
should be appointed to build the cupola, since in
doing that, his genius would be made manifest.
They took an egg accordingly, and all those masters
did their best to make it stand upright, but none
discovered the method of doing so. Wherefore,
Filippo, being told that he might make it stand himself,
took it daintily into his hand, gave the end of it
a blow on the plane of the marble, and made it stand
upright.[2] Beholding this, the artists loudly protested,
exclaiming that they could all have done the same;
but Filippo replied, laughing, that they might also
know how to construct the cupola, if they had seen
the model and design. It was thus at length resolved
that Filippo should receive the charge of conducting
the work, but was told that he must furnish the syndics
and wardens with more exact information.