the builders, having lost all power of proceeding;
for they were convinced that no method of constructing
the cupola would ever be found, nor any beams that
would make a scaffold strong enough to support the
framework and weight of so vast an edifice. The
Superintendents were therefore resolved to have an
end of the matter, and wrote to Filippo in Rome, entreating
him to repair to Florence, when he, who desired nothing
better, returned very readily. The wardens of
Santa Maria del Fiore and the syndics of the Guild
of Woolworkers, having assembled on his arrival, set
before him all the difficulties, from the greatest
to the smallest, which had been made by the masters,
who were present, together with himself, at the audience:
whereupon Filippo replied in these words—’Gentlemen
Superintendents, there is no doubt that great undertakings
always present difficulties in their execution; and
if none ever did so before, this of yours does it
to an extent of which you are not perhaps even yet
fully aware, for I do not know that even the ancients
ever raised so enormous a vault as this will be.
I, who have many times reflected on the scaffoldings
required, both within and without, and on the method
to be pursued for working securely at this erection,
have never been able to come to a decision; and I am
confounded, no less by the breadth than the height
of the edifice. Now, if the cupola could be arched
in a circular form, we might pursue the method adopted
by the Romans in erecting the Pantheon of Rome; that
is, the Rotunda. But here we must follow the
eight sides of the building, dove-tailing, and, so
to speak, enchaining the stones, which will be a very
difficult thing. Yet, remembering that this is
a temple consecrated to God and the Virgin, I confidently
trust, that for a work executed to their honor, they
will not fail to infuse knowledge where it is now
wanting, and will bestow strength, wisdom, and genius
on him who shall be the author of such a project.
But how can I help you in the matter, seeing that
the work is not mine? I tell you plainly, that
if it belonged to me, my courage and power would beyond
all doubt suffice to discover means whereby the work
might be effected without so many difficulties; but
as yet I have not reflected on the matter to any extent,
and you would have me tell you by what method it is
to be accomplished. But even if your worships
should determine that the cupola shall be raised,
you will be compelled not only to make trial of me,
who do not consider myself capable of being the sole
adviser in so important a matter, but also to expend
money, and to command that within a year, and on a
fixed day, many architects shall assemble in Florence;
not Tuscans and Italians only, but Germans, French,
and of every other nation: to them it is that
such an undertaking should be proposed, to the end
that having discussed the matter and decided among
so many masters, the work may be commenced and entrusted
to him who shall give the best evidence of capacity,
or shall display the best method and judgment for
the execution of so great a charge. I am not able
to offer you other counsel, or to propose a better
arrangement than this.’