some friend. At one time, it may be, he was
too ready with pardon; “You do not know,”
he said, “how hard it is to let a human being
die, when you feel that a stroke of your pen will
save him.” Butler used to write to him
that he was destroying the discipline of the army.
A letter of his to Meade shows clearly that, later
at least, he did not wish to exercise a merely cheap
and inconsiderate mercy. The import of the numberless
pardon stories really is that he would spare himself
no trouble to enquire, and to intervene wherever he
could rightly give scope to his longing for clemency.
A Congressman might force his way into his bedroom
in the middle of the night, rouse him from his sleep
to bring to his notice extenuating facts that had
been overlooked, and receive the decision, “Well,
I don’t see that it will do him any good to be
shot.” It is related that William Scott,
a lad from a farm in Vermont, after a tremendous march
in the Peninsula campaign, volunteered to do double
guard duty to spare a sick comrade, slept at his post,
was caught, and was under sentence of death, when
the President came to the army and heard of him.
The President visited him, chatted about his home,
looked at his mother’s photograph, and so forth.
Then he laid his hands on the boy’s shoulders
and said with a trembling voice, “My boy, you
are not going to be shot. I believe you when
you tell me that you could not keep awake. I
am going to trust you and send you back to the regiment.
But I have been put to a great deal of trouble on
your account. . . . Now what I want to know
is, how are you going to pay my bill?” Scott
told afterwards how difficult it was to think, when
his fixed expectation of death was suddenly changed;
but how he managed to master himself, thank Mr. Lincoln
and reckon up how, with his pay and what his parents
could raise by mortgage on their farm and some help
from his comrades, he might pay the bill if it were
not more than five or six hundred dollars. “But
it is a great deal more than that,” said the
President. “My bill is a very large one.
Your friends cannot pay it, nor your bounty, nor the
farm, nor all your comrades. There is only one
man in the world who can pay it, and his name is William
Scott. If from this day William Scott does his
duty, so that, when he comes to die, he can look me
in the face as he does now and say, ’I have
kept my promise and I have done my duty as a soldier,’
then my debt will be paid. Will you make the
promise and try to keep it?” And William Scott
did promise; and, not very long after, he was desperately
wounded, and he died, but not before he could send
a message to the President that he had tried to be
a good soldier, and would have paid his debt in full
if he had lived, and that he died thinking of Lincoln’s
kind face and thanking him for the chance he gave
him to fall like a soldier in battle. If the
story is not true—and there is no reason
whatever to doubt it—still it is a remarkable
man of whom people spin yarns of that kind.