and distressing appeals from them for help kept arriving
through the autumn; could they have been succoured
and their mountainous country occupied by the North,
a great stronghold of the Union would, it seemed to
Lincoln, have been planted securely far into the midst
of the Confederacy. Therefore he persistently
urged this part of his scheme on the attention of
his generals. The chief military objection raised
by Buell was that his army would have to advance 150
miles from the nearest base of supply upon a railway;
(for 200 miles to the west of the Alleghanies there
were no railways running from north to south).
To meet this Lincoln, in September, urged upon a
meeting of important Senators and Representatives the
construction of a railway line from Lexington in Kentucky
southwards, but his hearers, with their minds narrowed
down to an advance on Richmond, seem to have thought
the relatively small cost in time and money of this
work too great. Lincoln still thought an expedition
to Eastern Tennessee practicable at once, and it has
been argued from the circumstances in which one was
made nearly two years later that he was right.
It would, one may suppose, have been unwise to separate
the armies of the Ohio and of the West so widely;
for the main army of the Confederates in the West,
under their most trusted general, Albert Sidney Johnston,
was from September onwards in South-western Kentucky,
and could have struck at either of these two Northern
armies; and this was in Buell’s mind. On
the other hand, Lincoln’s object was a wise one
in itself and would have been worth some postponement
of the advance along the Mississippi if thereby the
army in the West could have been used in support of
it. However this may be, the fact is that Lincoln’s
plan, as it stood, was backed up by McClellan; McClellan
was perhaps unduly anxious for Buell to move on Eastern
Tennessee, because this would have supported the invasion
of Virginia which he himself was now contemplating,
and he was probably forgetful of the West; but he
was Lincoln’s highest military adviser and his
capacity was still trusted. Buell’s own
view was that, when he moved, it should be towards
Western Tennessee. He would have had a railway
connection behind him all his way, and Albert Johnston’s
army would have lain before him. He wished that
Halleck meanwhile should advance up the courses of
the Tennessee and Cumberland Rivers; Eastern Tennessee
(he may have thought) would be in the end more effectively
succoured; their two armies would thus have converged
on Johnston’s. Halleck agreed with Buell
to the extent of disagreeing with Lincoln and McClellan,
but no further. He declined to move in concert
with Buell. Fremont had disorganised the army
of the West, and Halleck, till he had repaired the
mischief, permitted only certain minor enterprises
under his command.