Christian church was made over, in its very cradle
to lies and to the father of lies, and was allowed
to remain in his keeping, so to say, till yesterday,
he will not much trouble himself with any faith which
after such an admission we may profess to entertain.
For as this spirit began in the first age in which
the church began to have a history; so it continued
so long as the church as an integral body retained
its vitality; and only died out in the degeneracy
which preceded, and which brought on the Reformation.
For fourteen hundred years these stories held their
place, and rang on from age to age, from century to
century; as the new faith widened its boundaries and
numbered ever more and more great names of men and
women who had fought and died for it, so long their
histories living in the hearts of those for whom they
laboured, laid hold of them and filled them, and the
devout imagination, possessed with what was often
no more than the rumour of a name, bodied it out into
life, and form, and reality. And doubtless, if
we try them by any historical canon, we have to say
that quite endless untruths grew in this way to be
believed among men; and not believed only, but held
sacred, passionately and devotedly; not filling the
history books only, not only serving to amuse and
edify the refectory, or to furnish matter for meditation
in the cell, but claiming days for themselves of special
remembrance, entering into liturgies and inspiring
prayers, forming the spiritual nucleus of the hopes
and fears of millions of human souls.
From the hard barren standing ground of the fact
idolater, what a strange sight must be that still mountain
peak on the wild west Irish shore, where for more
than ten centuries, a rude old bell and a carved chip
of oak have witnessed, or seemed to witness, to the
presence long ago there of the Irish apostle; and in
the sharp crystals of the trap rock a path has been
worn smooth by the bare feet and bleeding knees of
the pilgrims, who still, in the August weather, drag
their painful way along it as they have done for a
thousand years. Doubtless the “Lives of
the Saints” are full of lies. Are then
none in the Iliad? in the legends of AEneas?
Were the stories sung in the liturgy of Eleusis all
so true? so true as fact? Are the songs of the
Cid or of Siegfried? We say nothing of the lies
in these, but why? Oh, it will be said, but they
are fictions, they were never supposed to be true.
But they were supposed to be true, to the full as
true as the Legenda Aurea. Oh then, they are
poetry; and besides, they have nothing to do with
Christianity. Yes, that is it; they have nothing
to do with Christianity. It has grown such a
solemn business with us, and we bring such long faces
to it, that we cannot admit or conceive to be at all
naturally admissible such a light companion as the
imagination. The distinction between secular
and religious has been extended even to the faculties;
and we cannot tolerate in others the fulness and freedom