Reason is superior to matter. If, with the school
which extends from Pythagoras to Saint Augustine,
and from Saint Augustine to Descartes, we connect
reason with God as its principle, the grand science
of metaphysics is founded. But if reason does
not rise to God, what will happen? This reason,
which proclaims itself superior to matter, is not,
as we have said already, the individual thought of
Francis, Peter, or John. If an individual presented
himself as being reason itself, the absolute reason,
and said, “I am the truth,” it would be
necessary to take one of three courses. If we
thought that he spoke truly, and if we received his
testimony, it would be necessary to worship him, for
he would be God. If it were feared that he spoke
truly, and those who so feared were unwilling to acknowledge
his rule, it would be necessary for them to kill him
in order to endeavor to kill the truth. If it
were thought that he spoke falsely, it would be necessary
to watch him, and the moment he committed an act dangerous
for society, to shut him up, for he would be a madman.
But the philosophers make no such pretension.
The reason of which they speak is the reason common
to all, a reason which is not that of an individual,
but that of which all rational individuals partake.
This common, universal, eternal reason,—where
and how does it exist? Reason manifests itself
by ideas, and ideas are the acts of minds. To
imagine an idea without a mind of which it is the act,
is the same thing as to imagine a movement without
a body of which it is also the act, in a different
sense. Take away bodies, and there is no more
movement. Take away intelligences, and there
are no more ideas. The philosopher who speaks
of an idea which is not the idea of an intelligence,
utters words which have no meaning. The reason
which is not that of any created individual remains
therefore absolutely inconceivable without the eternal
Spirit, or God. Idealism is based upon this impossible
conception. Thus it is that thought, trying in
vain to maintain itself in this abstract domain, ends
by holding as chimerical the world of ideas in which
it has met with nothing to which to cling. It
is seized with giddiness and falls. Whither does
it fall? To the ground. It is always thither
one falls. Wearied with its efforts to find footing
on shifting clouds, the human mind comes back to the
positive by a violent reaction. Here is
the secret of that haughty and derisive materialism
of certain modern Germans, who jeer and scoff at the
lofty pretensions of philosophy. So it was that
Hegel brought upon the scene Doctor Buechner and his
fellows.