his thoughts may be vain. If man is the creature
of a wicked and cunning being, the light of reason
may be only an ignis fatuus kindled by a malicious
and mocking spirit. Here is a soul plunged in
the lowest abysses of doubt; but it is a manly soul
which seeks in doubt a trial for truth, and not a comfortable
pillow on which slothfully to repose. How does
Descartes upraise himself? By a thought known
to every one, and which was already found in St. Augustine:
“Cogito, ergo sum. I think, therefore
I am.” Deceive me who will; if I am deceived,
I exist. Here is a certainty protected from all
assault: I am. But what a poor certainty
is this! What does it avail me to have rescued
my existence from the abysses of universal doubt, if
above the deep waters which have swallowed up all belief
floats only this naked and mortifying truth:
I am; but I exist only perhaps to be the sport of
errors without end. The first step therefore taken
by the philosopher would be a fruitless one if it
were not followed by a second. An eye is open,
and says: I see; but it must have a warrant that
the light by which it sees is not a fantastic brightness.
No, replies Descartes; reason sees a true light; and
this is how he proves it: I am, I know myself;
that is certain. I know myself as a limited and
imperfect being; that again is certain. I conceive
then infinity and perfection; that is not less certain;
for I should not have the idea of a limit if I did
not conceive of infinity, and the word imperfect
would have no meaning for me, if I could not imagine
perfection, of which imperfection is but the negation.
Starting from this point, the philosopher proves by
a series of reasonings that the conception of perfection
by our minds demonstrates the real existence of that
perfection: God is. He adds, that the existence
of God is more certain than the most certain of all
the theorems of geometry. You will observe, Gentlemen,
that the man who speaks in this way is one of the
greatest geometricians that ever lived. He has
found God, he has found the light. Reason does
not deceive, when it is faithful to its own laws:
the senses do not deceive, when they are exercised
according to the rules of the understanding. Error
is a malady; it is not the radical condition of our
nature; it is not without limits and without remedy,
for the final cause of our being is God, that is to
say truth and goodness.
From everlasting God
was true,
For ever good and just
will be,
says one of our old psalms. Faith in the veracity of God—such is the ground of the assurance of believers; such is also the foundation on which has been raised the greatest of modern philosophies. Without the knowledge of God and faith in his goodness, man remains plunged in irremediable doubt, possessing only this single, poor, and frightful certainty: I am; and I exist perhaps only to be eternally deceived.