[Footnote 195: Cf., for instance, the Madonna over the door of the Pisa Baptistery.]
[Footnote 196: Cf. drawings of ewers in Uffizzi by Giacomone da Faenza, sixteenth century.]
* * * * *
[Illustration: Alinari
MIRACLE OF THE SPEAKING BABE
SANT’ ANTONIO, PADUA]
[Illustration: Alinari
MIRACLE OF THE MISER’S HEART
SANT’ ANTONIO, PADUA]
[Illustration: Alinari
MIRACLE OF THE MULE
SANT’ ANTONIO, PADUA]
[Sidenote: The Bronze Reliefs.]
The four panels of Miracles take the highest rank among Donatello’s bas-reliefs. Their size is considerable, being about four feet long. They have one theme in common, namely, the supernatural gifts of St. Anthony and the veneration of the populace. Donatello’s crowds are admirable; they are deep crowds. The people are rather hot and jostling each other: they stand on benches or stairs in order to get a better view of what is proceeding. The edges of the crowds, where the people are too far off to be active spectators, lose interest in the central incident; they gossip as bystanders or sit down: often they are shown actually leaving the place. It is singular how ill-designed many of the classical crowds are, especially the battle-scenes: they are constructed without regard for the human necessity of standing on something; and we have grotesque topsy-turvy compositions, the individual parts of which are unrivalled in technique.[197] Michael Angelo’s first and last representation of a crowd in sculpture shows the same fault, which, indeed, was far from uncommon.[198] It arose from a desire to show more of the crowd than could be naturally seen from the eye level, and the whole relief was consequently covered with figures, the background proper being suppressed. In these Paduan reliefs Donatello manages to give ample density and variety, and there is never any doubt as to the ownership of legs or arms. His early relief at Siena, on the other hand, has a group