of vandalism are indeed strange and varied. In
this case vanity was responsible. It was superstition
which led the Sienese, after incurring defeat by the
Florentines, to remove from their market-place the
famous statue by Lysippus which brought them ill-luck,
and to bury it in Florentine territory, so that their
enemies might suffer instead. Ignorance nearly
induced a Pope to destroy the “Last Judgment”
of Michael Angelo, whose colossal statue of an earlier
Pontiff, Julius II., was broken up through political
animosity. One wishes that in this last case
there had been some practical provision such as that
inserted by the House of Lords in the order for destroying
the Italian Tombs at Windsor in 1645, when they ordained
that “they that buy the tombs shall have liberty
to transport them beyond the seas, for making the
best advantage of them.” The vandalism which
dispersed Donatello’s work could not even claim
to be utilitarian, like that which so nearly caused
the destruction of the famous chapel by Benozzo Gozzoli
in the Riccardi Palace (for the purposes of a new
staircase);[2] neither was it caused by the exigencies
of war, such as the demolition of the Monastery of
San Donato, a treasure-house of early painting, razed
to the ground by the Florentines when awaiting the
siege of 1529. The Cathedral facade was hastily
removed, and only a fraction of the statuary has survived.
Two figures are in the Louvre; another has been recently
presented to the Cathedral by the Duca di Sermoneta,
himself a Caetani, of Boniface VIII., a portrait-statue
even more remarkable than that of the same Pope at
Bologna. Four more figures from the old facade,
now standing outside the Porta Romana of Florence,
are misused and saddened relics. They used to
be the major prophets, but on translation were crowned
with laurels, and now represent Homer, Virgil, Dante
and Petrarch. Other statues are preserved inside
the Cathedral. Before dealing with these it is
necessary to point out how difficult it is to determine
the authorship and identity of the surviving figures.
In the first place, our materials for reconstructing
the design of the old facade are few. There were
various pictures, some of which in their turn have
perished, where guidance might have been expected.
But the representations of the Cathedral in frescoes
at San Marco, Santa Croce, the Misericordia and Santa
Maria Novella help us but little. Up to the eighteenth
century there used to be a model in the Opera del
Duomo: this also has vanished, and we are compelled
to make our deductions from a rather unsatisfactory
drawing made by Bernardo Pocetti in the sixteenth
century. It shows the disposition of statuary
so sketchily that we can only recognise a few of the
figures. But we have a perfect idea of the general
style and aim of those who planned the facade, which
would have far surpassed the rival frontispieces of
Siena, Pisa and Orvieto. We are met by a further
difficulty in identifying the surviving statues from