influence, a tonic: it was a living protest against
flippancy and carelessness, and his influence was
of service even where it was of a purely negative
character. Through Bertoldo Donatello’s
influence extended to Michael Angelo, affecting his
ideas of form: But Jacopo della Quercia, who was
almost as great a man as Donatello, is the prototype
of Michael Angelo’s spirit. Jacopo ought
to have founded a powerful, indeed an overwhelming
school of sculpture at Siena. Cozzarelli, Neroccio,
and the Turini just fail to attain distinction; but
their force and virility should have fructified Jacopo’s
ideas and developed a supreme school of monumental
sculpture. As regards Michael Angelo, there can
be no question of his having been influenced by Donatello’s
St. John the Evangelist and the Campanile Abraham.
The
Madonna delle treppe[242] in a lesser degree
is suggested by Donatello. The Trinity on the
niche of St. Louis again reminds one of Michael Angelo’s
conception of the Eternal Father. His Bacchus
in Berlin[243] was held to be the work of Donatello
himself, and the Pieta in St. Peter’s has also
a reminiscence of the older master. But in all
these cases the resemblance is physical. The
intellectual genius of Michael Angelo owed nothing
to Donatello. Condivi records one of Michael Angelo’s
rare
obiter dicta about his predecessors[244]
to the effect that Donatello’s work, much as
he admired it, was inadequately polished owing to
lack of patience. The criticism was not very sagacious,
and one would least expect it from Michael Angelo,
of whose work so much was left unfinished. But,
at any rate, Donatello commanded his approval, and
contributed something to one of the greatest artists
of the world. But the ideals of Michael Angelo
were too comprehensive to be derived from one source
or another, too stupendous to spring from individuals.
He sought out the universal form: he took mankind
for his model; and while he typified humanity he effectively
denationalised Italian sculpture.
[Footnote 241: E.g., work wrongly attributed
to Donatello: the figure of Plenty in the courtyard
of the Canigiani Palace, Florence; the Lavabo in San
Lorenzo; the two figures on the famous silver altar
at Pistoja; the bronze busts in the Bargello; the font
at Pietra Santa; chimney-pieces, gateways, stemme,
and numberless Madonnas and small bronzes.]
[Footnote 242: Casa Buonarroti, Florence.]
[Footnote 243: From the Gualandi Collection.
It is attributed by some to a Neapolitan sculptor.]
[Footnote 244: “Vita,” 1553, p. 14.]
* * * *
*
[Sidenote: Early Criticism of Donatello.]
Donatello’s activity is the best testimonial
to the appreciation of his work during his lifetime.
Sabba del Castiglione was proud to possess a specimen
of Donatello’s sculpture.[245] Commissions were
showered on him in great numbers, and Gauricus says
that he produced more than all his contemporaries.[246]
Flavius Blondius of Forli compares him favourably
with the ancients.[247] Bartolomeo Fazio warmly praised
Donatello, his junior.[248] Francesco d’Olanda[249]
and Benvenuto Cellini[250] also admired him.
Lasca credited Donatello with having done for sculpture
what Brunellesco did for architecture: