Writing the Photoplay eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 385 pages of information about Writing the Photoplay.

Writing the Photoplay eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 385 pages of information about Writing the Photoplay.

6.  General Advice

It is most important that, having started to write a farce, for instance, you keep it a farce throughout.  One fault of many amateur scripts is that they show a tendency to be a little of everything.  A strong emotional drama may—­even should—­have its “comedy relief,” but it is a very unwise thing to introduce a note of tragedy into a farce or even into a straight comedy composition.

At this point it will not be out of place to say a few words in connection with this matter of “comedy relief,” of which we have just spoken, as used in writing dramatic stories.  The over-use of comedy relief, so called, is mostly due to misguided directors who have seen the success attending its introduction by prominent directors who really understood how and when to use it.  A departmental writer in the Motion Picture News, speaking of the small army of directors “who worked with Griffith,” says: 

“Probably the most obvious of all the blunders made by the men who seek to emulate the wonderful work of Griffith is their introduction of comedy, chiefly through the medium of domestic animals, when they are forced to stop the action of their story to do so.  Griffith’s comedy is always spontaneous, incidental—­it seems to have been inspired at the moment and runs in as part of the main action.  The comedy of the men ‘who worked with Griffith,’ while perhaps inspired at the moment, rises not from the situations of the story but from the contemplative mind of the director himself.  This is the general rule, at any rate.  There are exceptions, of course, and notable ones, too, but that all-powerful motif of ‘comedy relief’ often gets the better of the director’s judgment and results in a product that is so unbalanced that much of the illusion is destroyed.  In fact, comedy relief is a difficult element to gain.  It should always be purely incidental, unforced, arising from some major situation, and so creating the desired contrast.  When it is obviously sought after and introduced without regard for its suitability it is not comedy relief but comedy-out-of-place.”

Since this, like the over-use of the close-up, is something for which directors are largely responsible, it is the photoplaywright’s duty to help by being very careful about how he himself writes in comedy intended to “light up” tense, serious, dramatic action.

No matter what class of humorous photoplay you may be writing, you must keep in mind what we enlarged upon in Chapter XVI:  Nothing is funny that offends against good taste, or that, in any way, causes pain to any number of the spectators.  Comedy, to be worthy of appreciation, must always be good-natured.  National types as caricatured by many comedians with the aid of eccentric costumes and weird make-ups are usually as far from being real national types as one could well imagine.  Humor must have more than mere extravagance or caricature for its basis. 

Copyrights
Project Gutenberg
Writing the Photoplay from Project Gutenberg. Public domain.