Admiral Coligny in Westminster Cathedral. . . .
I rose from my knees a new Luther, with something like
a Protestant feeling, and scrutinised severely the
tombs in Poets’ Corner. Even there I found
myself confronted with an almost irritating liberalism.
Here was Alexander Pope, who rejected all the overtures
of Swift and Atterbury to embrace the Protestant faith.
And there was Dryden, not, perhaps, a great ornament
to my persuasion, but still a Catholic at the last.
Dean Panther had not grudged poet Hind his niche
in the National Valhalla (I knew I should be reduced
to that periphrasis). And here was the mighty
Charles Darwin, about whose reception into the English
Pantheon (I have fallen again) I remember there was
some trouble. Well, if precedent embalms a principle,
I venture to raise a thin small voice, and plead for
Herbert Spencer. ‘The English people,’
said a friendly French critic, ’do not admire
their great men because they were great, but because
they reflect credit on themselves.’ So
on the score of national vanity I claim space for
Herbert Spencer. Very few Englishmen have exercised
such extraordinary influence on continental opinion,
which Beaconsfield said was the verdict of posterity.
On the news of his death, the Italian Chamber passed
a vote of condolence with the English people.
I suppose that does not seem a great honour to Englishmen,
but to me, an enemy of United Italy, it seemed a great
honour, not only to the dead but to the English people.
Can you imagine the Swiss Federal Council sending
us a vote of condolence on the death of Mr. Hall Caine
or Mr. Robert Hichens?
Again, though it is ungrateful of me to mention the
fact after my experiences of October 13th, the Abbey
was not built nor endowed by people who anticipated
the Anglican form of worship being celebrated within
its walls, though I admit it has been restored
by the adherents of that communion. The image
of Milton, to take only one instance, would have been
quite as objectionable to Henry III. or Abbot Islip
as those of Darwin or Spencer. The emoluments
bequeathed by Henry VII. and others for requiem masses
are now devoted to the education of Deans’ daughters
and Canons’ sons. Where incensed altars
used to stand, hideous monuments of the sixteenth,
seventeenth, and eighteenth centuries wound the Gothic
air with their monstrous ornaments and inapposite epitaphs.
St. Paul’s may fairly be held sacred to Anglicanism,
and I do not think any one would claim sepulture within
its precincts for one who was avowedly hostile to
Christian or Anglican sentiment. But I think
the Abbey has now passed into the category of museums,
and might well be declared a national monument under
control of the State. The choir, and possibly
the nave, should, of course, be severely preserved
for whatever the State religion might be at the time.
Catholics need not mourn the secularisation of the
transepts and chapels, because Leo XIII. renounced
officially all claims on the ancient shrines of the
Catholic faith, and High Churchmen might console themselves
by recalling the fact that Abbots were originally
laymen.